Connect with us


Opinion: Implementing a carve out could jeopardize California’s coastal protections

urlhttps3A2F2Fcalifornia times brightspot.s3.amazonaws.com2F312F1f2Fa0f8bebe40e58a4941f2263221802Fhttps delivery gettyimages.com2Fdownloads2F1259103799

If the coast of California is a state asset worth trillions of dollars — and it is — why is the state agency that has successfully protected that asset for 50 years under assault? The answer — “unnecessary permitting delays” — is unfounded. Yet California’s exceptional history of coastal protection is in greater jeopardy today in the halls of our state Capitol than it has been for generations.

Like water flowing downhill, California’s incomparable coast has always been a magnet for development. In 1972, with this in mind, the voters of California overwhelmingly approved Proposition 20, a ballot initiative that set in motion the 1976 California Coastal Act. Unlike South Florida, the Jersey Shore or other coastal regions devoured by privatization, the California coast was by law given special protection: The coastal zone would be developed not as an enclave for the wealthy but for everyone’s use, with provisions for protecting its natural resources and its breathtaking beauty.

The California Coastal Commission was created to enforce the act with a specific charge to balance the needs of the ecosystem with the need for public access and economic development, including affordable housing. It works like this: Local jurisdictions come up with coastal plans that the commission must approve. Once a plan is in place, development permits are handled by the city, town or county, although those decisions can be appealed to and by the commission.

Over the years, the Coastal Commission has successfully defended public access to the beach in Malibu, Half Moon Bay, Carlsbad and other towns. It has helped preserve state parks, open space along the coast and the beach itself — denying permits for oil drilling, more than one luxury resort, an LNG port (in Oxnard) and a toll road (at San Onofre Beach). In 2019, it fined a developer nearly $15.6 million for replacing, without a permit, two low-cost hotels along Ocean Avenue in Santa Monica with a boutique hotel.

Check Out Also:  Potential Inhabitability of Europa’s Oceans in Doubt

Predictably, this process has often been in the bull’s-eye of Coastal Act critics, and while the rationale may vary with the moment, their goal remains the same: To weaken oversight by the commission and return land-use control entirely to local governments.

Today, low affordable housing supply along the coast is the basis for attack. In legislation introduced in January, with a purpose of “resolving unnecessary permitting delays in the disproportionately low-housing Coastal Zone,” state Sen. Scott Wiener (D-San Francisco) has proposed an unprecedented carve out of 23.5% of the coastal zone in San Francisco. Specifically, Senate Bill 951 would delete from commission oversight residential areas on the city’s western edge, as well as a piece of Golden Gate Park. As the first significant coastal zone reduction in more than 40 years, this attack on the commission could set a dangerous precedent that would invite similar carve outs from San Diego to Santa Monica to Crescent City.

Last month, San Francisco’s Board of Supervisors voted overwhelmingly to oppose SB 951, and, one day later, the Coastal Commission, by unanimous vote, did the same.

The existential threat that this legislation poses to the Coastal Act and the entire California coast is undeniable. Among numerous commission responsibilities affected, SB 951 ignores the agency’s essential role in planning for sea-level rise adaptation along San Francisco’s increasingly vulnerable coast. And it seems no mere coincidence that the excluded area includes land proposed for a controversial 50-story condominium and commercial project in the flats of the Outer Sunset neighborhood north of the San Francisco Zoo.

Check Out Also:  Playing the Joke at the Inaugural Florida Man Games

The claim that the Coastal Commission is responsible for housing inequity in the coastal zone, though long on rhetoric, is belied by the historical record. Indeed, when the Coastal Act became law in 1976, it required that “housing for persons of low and moderate income shall be protected, encouraged, and, where feasible, provided.” The commission actively complied, approving or protecting from demolition more than 7,100 affordable units between 1977 and 1981 and collecting an estimated $2 million in “in lieu” fees to support affordable housing.

But in 1981, the state Legislature amended the Coastal Act to remove the commission’s affordable housing authority. Contrary to the claim of “unnecessary permitting delays” on which SB 951 is based — only two coastal development permits in San Francisco have been appealed to the commission in 38 years — it is this amendment, and the fact that developers prefer to build high-end projects, that has produced today’s affordable housing deficit in the coastal zone. As then-Coastal Commission Chair Leonard Grote warned in 1981, “The passage of this bill would make sure that the ability to live near the coast is reserved for the wealthy.” And so it has.

If increasing the supply of affordable housing near California’s coast is actually the goal of SB 951, then restoring, not reducing, the commission’s authority is needed. It was a mistake in 1981 to remove the commission’s power to require that projects it approved included affordable housing, and it’s a mistake in 2024 to expect that diminishing the coastal zone will right that wrong.

Check Out Also:  Man dies following alleged assault on San Bernardino County deputy

The California Coastal Commission has an extraordinary record of success in protecting California’s most valuable environmental and economic resource, and its regulatory role is as essential today as it has ever been. SB 951 would weaken, not promote, equal access to that resource, and it threatens to erode, perhaps irrevocably, the most successful coastal management program in the country.

Joel Reynolds is western director and senior attorney for the Natural Resources Defense Council in Santa Monica. Tom Soto is a former alternate member of the California Coastal Commission and a Natural Resources Defense Council board member.

cropped cropped cropped cropped cropped Intellectuals Insider
+ posts
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Immigration in Maine Addressing Labor Shortage Could Set Trend for U.S.

00dc immigecon 01 mkzh facebookJumbo

A significant labor gap in Maine’s lobster industry is being filled by immigrants, shedding light on the critical role that foreign-born workers are likely to play in the U.S. economy as the native-born population ages. Maine, known for its abundant lobster population, is grappling with an aging workforce that is increasingly unable to sustain the demands of the thriving lobster industry, valued at $1 billion.

Ben Conniff, a founder of Luke’s Lobster, underscores the importance of immigrants in sustaining the natural resources economy of the state, as many native-born workers are not inclined towards manufacturing work in food processing. Since its establishment in 2013, Luke’s Lobster has heavily relied on immigrants to staff its lobster processing plant, highlighting the vital role played by foreign-born workers in filling labor gaps.

With Maine boasting the oldest population in the U.S., with a median age of 45.1, the state offers a glimpse into the economic future of America, where immigrants are poised to be a crucial source of new workers and economic vitality in the coming years.

As immigration continues to be a hotly debated topic in the country, the influx of immigrants has been instrumental in boosting the American economy’s potential. The Congressional Budget Office has revised upwards its population and economic growth projections for the next decade, attributing the growth to the wave of newcomers entering the workforce.

Maine’s initiatives to attract and integrate immigrants into the workforce, such as the creation of an Office of New Americans, reflect the state’s proactive approach towards addressing labor shortages. Private companies like Luke’s Lobster have also taken steps to diversify and supplement the aging lobster fishing industry by training immigrants and minorities in lobster fishing and licensing processes.

Check Out Also:  Pentagon Report Confirms No UFO Cover-Up, Yet Debate Persists

Chadai Gatembo, an 18-year-old immigrant from the Democratic Republic of Congo, exemplifies the success story of immigrants finding opportunities in Maine. Despite facing challenges on his journey to the U.S., Gatembo is now on the path to becoming a full-fledged lobsterman, showcasing the potential for immigrants to thrive in new industries.

The influx of immigrants is not without its challenges, with issues of work authorization and economic stability confronting many newcomers. Adriana Hernandez, a mother of four from Venezuela, highlights the economic hardship faced by immigrants awaiting work permits, underscoring the barriers faced by unauthorized workers in integrating into the labor market.

Despite these challenges, the overall impact of immigration on the U.S. economy is significant. Immigrants have helped to bolster job growth, insulate the economy against downturns, and contribute to a more diverse and innovative workforce. Economists predict that immigration will play a crucial role in addressing labor shortages and demographic shifts as the native-born population ages.

The entrepreneurial spirit of immigrants like Chenda Chamreoun, who has risen from lobster cleaning to a quality assurance supervisor and now aims to start her own catering business, showcases the economic potential of foreign-born workers. Immigrants tend to be more entrepreneurial, adding to the innovation and productivity of the American economy.

J. Edward Moreno contributed reporting from New York, and Zolan Kanno-Youngs from Washington.

cropped cropped cropped cropped cropped Intellectuals Insider
Check Out Also:  Ancient Frescoes discovered in Pompeii Ash 2,000 years post Vesuvius Eruption
+ posts
Continue Reading


00dc immigecon 01 mkzh facebookJumbo 00dc immigecon 01 mkzh facebookJumbo
News49 mins ago

Immigration in Maine Addressing Labor Shortage Could Set Trend for U.S.

A significant labor gap in Maine’s lobster industry is being filled by immigrants, shedding light on the critical role that...

12934 12934
News4 hours ago

The Contribution of Volcanoes to Venus’s Atmospheric Composition

One of the many mysteries surrounding Venus, our closest planetary neighbor, is the origin of its atmosphere. The planet is...

urlhttps3A2F2Fcalifornia times brightspot.s3.amazonaws.com2F282F312F65b5b7234294a97151f8508d23f92Fla me sf mosque urlhttps3A2F2Fcalifornia times brightspot.s3.amazonaws.com2F282F312F65b5b7234294a97151f8508d23f92Fla me sf mosque
News5 hours ago

San Francisco man taken into custody for allegedly defacing mosque

San Francisco man Robert Gray, 35, was arrested on Wednesday evening for allegedly vandalizing a mosque in Nob Hill. He...

AI MISTRAL 01 lcjm facebookJumbo AI MISTRAL 01 lcjm facebookJumbo
News6 hours ago

Europe’s Leading Artificial Intelligence Company Targets Tech Giants in the United States.

With the rise of artificial intelligence (A.I.) technology shaping the future of global economies, Europe is setting its sights on...

79919033 79919033
Entertainment8 hours ago

Daughter of Wynonna Judd Faces Solicitation Charges Following Indecent Exposure Arrest

Wynonna Judd’s daughter, Grace Kelley, has found herself in legal trouble once again. The 27-year-old has been formally charged with...

phobos su phobos su
News9 hours ago

Was a Prehistoric Icy Object Responsible for Forming the Moons of Mars?

The Martian moons Phobos and Deimos have always been a subject of fascination for astronomers. Unlike other moons in the...

urlhttps3A2F2Fcalifornia times brightspot.s3.amazonaws.com2F132F622F227fc08244d0a8ef4d9acfb30b5d2Fmissing college student murder trial 07017 urlhttps3A2F2Fcalifornia times brightspot.s3.amazonaws.com2F132F622F227fc08244d0a8ef4d9acfb30b5d2Fmissing college student murder trial 07017
News11 hours ago

Prison stabbing injures Paul Flores, convicted murderer of Kristin Smart

Paul Flores, the man convicted of killing Kristin Smart, was stabbed in state prison just eight months after being attacked...

11brooks facebookJumbo v2 11brooks facebookJumbo v2
News12 hours ago

A Celebration of Middle Managers: An Opinion

Middle managers are often overlooked in discussions about leadership and management, but they play a crucial role in organizations. In...

gettyimages 1373357463 gettyimages 1373357463
News13 hours ago

Pharmacists issue warning about shortages of hundreds of drugs

A growing number of drugs are in short supply around the U.S., according to pharmacists. In the first three months...

NASA Advanced Composite Solar Sail NASA Advanced Composite Solar Sail
News15 hours ago

NASA’s Upcoming Solar Sail Mission Set to Launch into Space

Everyone understands that solar energy is abundant and practically limitless here on Earth. The same principle applies to spacecraft operating...