Connect with us


Changes in legal interpretation of the 2nd Amendment have broader implications than firearm regulations

urlhttps3A2F2Fcalifornia times brightspot.s3.amazonaws.com2F542F5f2F28327c38484c82052695417b80e62Fgettyimages 175222742

In 2021, U.S. District Judge Roger T. Benitez ruled that a 100-year-old California ban on stick-like weapons known as “billy clubs” was constitutional precisely because it was so “longstanding.”

Last week, Benitez, reviewing the case for a second time, ruled the opposite: The ban is unconstitutional because it isn’t old enough.

“What is different today,” the judge wrote, “is that a statute enacted in 1923 is no longer given a pass for being ‘longstanding.’ ”

Benitez’s reversal was the latest example of the rapidly shifting landscape for 2nd Amendment law in the country — not just for firearms, but all sorts of other weapons. Beyond billy clubs, laws banning butterfly knives, switchblades, and other edged weapons are also being challenged.

In the 2022 case New York State Rifle & Pistol Assn. vs. Bruen, the U.S. Supreme Court said that state restrictions on the 2nd Amendment are legitimate only if they are deeply rooted in American “history and tradition” or closely analogous to some other historic law.

To be relevant under such an analysis, the high court said, a law or similar prohibition would have to date back to either 1791 when the 2nd Amendment was adopted or 1868 when the 14th Amendment and its related due process protections were adopted.

The ruling shook American jurisprudence around firearms to the core. It prompted challenges to state gun laws to be filed all over the country and revived many other weapons cases that had been failing to gain traction in the courts.

Benitez — a George W. Bush appointee lovingly referred to as “Saint Benitez” by gun rights supporters — has previously struck down various California gun laws in light of the Bruen decision, including the state’s bans on assault-style weapons and high-capacity magazines.

The state is appealing those decisions, and California Atty. Gen. Rob Bonta’s office promptly notified the court that it would be appealing the billy club ruling, too, which it said in a statement “defies logic” and “contradicts” the Bruen decision in a way that “puts public safety at risk.”

Check Out Also:  Gemini North Telescope Gallery

As the case makes clear, the standard set by Bruen is reaching far beyond rifles and handguns.

“The 2nd Amendment protects a right to bear arms,” said Adam Winkler, a UCLA law professor focused on 2nd Amendment law, “and the Supreme Court has made it clear that that is not limited to firearms.”

Across the U.S., state laws bar a plethora of weapons, from blades to blunt instruments.

All are now fair game for toppling in the eyes of gun rights and other weapons enthusiasts who view any restriction as an infringement on their right to bear arms.

Legal cases concerning weapons other than firearms present some distinct issues but largely now hinge on the same Bruen-inspired historical analyses that gun cases rely on, experts said. Lower district and appellate court judges are still grappling with the Bruen test and how to apply it, the experts said, leaving the legal landscape unsettled.

“Bruen is so inherently ambiguous, and the [history and tradition] test so unfamiliar to judges, that there are just fundamental disagreements,” Winkler said. “It’s wholly foreign to the courts to look solely to history and tradition to determine the scope of the government’s regulatory power, and they don’t really know how to do it.”

In August, a conservative three-judge panel of the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that a 30-year ban on butterfly knives in Hawaii was unconstitutional in light of Bruen, threatening such laws not just in Hawaii but in California and across the country.

“Hawaii has not demonstrated that its ban on butterfly knives is consistent with this Nation’s historical tradition of regulating arms,” Judge Carlos Bea, an appointee of President George W. Bush, wrote for the court.

Butterfly knives have split handles that swing back to form a single handle when the blade inside is revealed. Hawaii and other states that ban them, including California, have argued they present a particular public danger, and that there are historic laws outlawing particularly dangerous blades to justify restrictions under Bruen.

Check Out Also:  Nvidia Reports Record Profits and Revenue as AI Industry Surges

Late last week, the 9th Circuit said that it was taking the case back up to be reconsidered by a larger, 11-judge en banc panel. Such a decision suggests that at least some of the court’s judges also question whether the law under Bruen was appropriately applied in the case.

Benitez’s latest ruling on billy clubs also faces further review.

Such weapons have been poorly defined in state law but broadly construed in the past to include the sort of swinging batons once popular among police, as well as other wooden clubs, bats, and batons.

Benitez found that such weapons have long been used for self-defense, and that in the relevant historical eras under Bruen, there were no sufficiently similar bans on them. Therefore, California’s ban is unconstitutional and cannot be enforced, he ruled.

“One can easily imagine countless citizens carrying these weapons on daily walks and hikes to defend themselves against attacks by humans or animals,” Benitez wrote. “To give full life to the core right of self-defense, every law-abiding responsible individual citizen has a constitutionally protected right to keep and bear arms like the billy for lawful purposes.”

Bonta’s office said the ruling, if allowed to stand, would legalize in California modern, steel batons that telescope into themselves and can be easily concealed and “used in public disturbances or riots,” as they were during the Jan. 6, 2021, attack on the U.S. Capitol.

“The Supreme Court was clear that Bruen did not create a regulatory straitjacket for states — and we believe that the district court got this wrong,” Bonta’s office said. “We will not stop in our efforts to protect the safety of communities.”

Alan Beck is counsel for the plaintiffs in both the California billy club case and the Hawaii butterfly knife case. He called California’s billy club ban “a very vague and nebulous law that has been abused for decades in California.”

Beck said the law has been cited by police and prosecutors to charge people for carrying a table leg and a skateboard and clearly ran afoul of the history test under Bruen.

Check Out Also:  Russia's Extensive Security Services Failed in Preventing Deadly Attack

“It’s common sense that the colonial era didn’t ban people from carrying sticks around or owning sticks in their house,” he said.

He said such laws are clearly unconstitutional because there “are a lot of people who aren’t comfortable carrying a firearm, who would like some mechanism for self-defense.”

Benitez made a similar point in his ruling last week, where he described a theoretical “young girl” being arrested for carrying a billy club while walking home from school in “a part of town where robberies, assaults, and rapes have occurred; where youth gangs are known to frequent; and where unrestrained dogs are known to roam.”

“And why does California elect to make this girl a criminal? Because there is a risk, no matter how small, that the girl might use [the club] for an unlawful purpose, or that others may use similar weapons for unlawful purposes,” Benitez wrote. “The United States Constitution prohibits such intrusions into an otherwise law-abiding citizen’s choice for self-defense.”

cropped cropped cropped cropped cropped Intellectuals Insider
+ posts
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Immigration in Maine Addressing Labor Shortage Could Set Trend for U.S.

00dc immigecon 01 mkzh facebookJumbo

A significant labor gap in Maine’s lobster industry is being filled by immigrants, shedding light on the critical role that foreign-born workers are likely to play in the U.S. economy as the native-born population ages. Maine, known for its abundant lobster population, is grappling with an aging workforce that is increasingly unable to sustain the demands of the thriving lobster industry, valued at $1 billion.

Ben Conniff, a founder of Luke’s Lobster, underscores the importance of immigrants in sustaining the natural resources economy of the state, as many native-born workers are not inclined towards manufacturing work in food processing. Since its establishment in 2013, Luke’s Lobster has heavily relied on immigrants to staff its lobster processing plant, highlighting the vital role played by foreign-born workers in filling labor gaps.

With Maine boasting the oldest population in the U.S., with a median age of 45.1, the state offers a glimpse into the economic future of America, where immigrants are poised to be a crucial source of new workers and economic vitality in the coming years.

As immigration continues to be a hotly debated topic in the country, the influx of immigrants has been instrumental in boosting the American economy’s potential. The Congressional Budget Office has revised upwards its population and economic growth projections for the next decade, attributing the growth to the wave of newcomers entering the workforce.

Maine’s initiatives to attract and integrate immigrants into the workforce, such as the creation of an Office of New Americans, reflect the state’s proactive approach towards addressing labor shortages. Private companies like Luke’s Lobster have also taken steps to diversify and supplement the aging lobster fishing industry by training immigrants and minorities in lobster fishing and licensing processes.

Check Out Also:  Akira Toriyama, the Creator of 'Dragon Ball,' Passes Away at the Age of 68

Chadai Gatembo, an 18-year-old immigrant from the Democratic Republic of Congo, exemplifies the success story of immigrants finding opportunities in Maine. Despite facing challenges on his journey to the U.S., Gatembo is now on the path to becoming a full-fledged lobsterman, showcasing the potential for immigrants to thrive in new industries.

The influx of immigrants is not without its challenges, with issues of work authorization and economic stability confronting many newcomers. Adriana Hernandez, a mother of four from Venezuela, highlights the economic hardship faced by immigrants awaiting work permits, underscoring the barriers faced by unauthorized workers in integrating into the labor market.

Despite these challenges, the overall impact of immigration on the U.S. economy is significant. Immigrants have helped to bolster job growth, insulate the economy against downturns, and contribute to a more diverse and innovative workforce. Economists predict that immigration will play a crucial role in addressing labor shortages and demographic shifts as the native-born population ages.

The entrepreneurial spirit of immigrants like Chenda Chamreoun, who has risen from lobster cleaning to a quality assurance supervisor and now aims to start her own catering business, showcases the economic potential of foreign-born workers. Immigrants tend to be more entrepreneurial, adding to the innovation and productivity of the American economy.

J. Edward Moreno contributed reporting from New York, and Zolan Kanno-Youngs from Washington.

cropped cropped cropped cropped cropped Intellectuals Insider
Check Out Also:  7.4 Magnitude Earthquake Strikes Near Taiwan, Causing Island Shaking and Tsunami Alerts
+ posts
Continue Reading


00dc immigecon 01 mkzh facebookJumbo 00dc immigecon 01 mkzh facebookJumbo
News1 hour ago

Immigration in Maine Addressing Labor Shortage Could Set Trend for U.S.

A significant labor gap in Maine’s lobster industry is being filled by immigrants, shedding light on the critical role that...

12934 12934
News4 hours ago

The Contribution of Volcanoes to Venus’s Atmospheric Composition

One of the many mysteries surrounding Venus, our closest planetary neighbor, is the origin of its atmosphere. The planet is...

urlhttps3A2F2Fcalifornia times brightspot.s3.amazonaws.com2F282F312F65b5b7234294a97151f8508d23f92Fla me sf mosque urlhttps3A2F2Fcalifornia times brightspot.s3.amazonaws.com2F282F312F65b5b7234294a97151f8508d23f92Fla me sf mosque
News5 hours ago

San Francisco man taken into custody for allegedly defacing mosque

San Francisco man Robert Gray, 35, was arrested on Wednesday evening for allegedly vandalizing a mosque in Nob Hill. He...

AI MISTRAL 01 lcjm facebookJumbo AI MISTRAL 01 lcjm facebookJumbo
News7 hours ago

Europe’s Leading Artificial Intelligence Company Targets Tech Giants in the United States.

With the rise of artificial intelligence (A.I.) technology shaping the future of global economies, Europe is setting its sights on...

79919033 79919033
Entertainment9 hours ago

Daughter of Wynonna Judd Faces Solicitation Charges Following Indecent Exposure Arrest

Wynonna Judd’s daughter, Grace Kelley, has found herself in legal trouble once again. The 27-year-old has been formally charged with...

phobos su phobos su
News10 hours ago

Was a Prehistoric Icy Object Responsible for Forming the Moons of Mars?

The Martian moons Phobos and Deimos have always been a subject of fascination for astronomers. Unlike other moons in the...

urlhttps3A2F2Fcalifornia times brightspot.s3.amazonaws.com2F132F622F227fc08244d0a8ef4d9acfb30b5d2Fmissing college student murder trial 07017 urlhttps3A2F2Fcalifornia times brightspot.s3.amazonaws.com2F132F622F227fc08244d0a8ef4d9acfb30b5d2Fmissing college student murder trial 07017
News11 hours ago

Prison stabbing injures Paul Flores, convicted murderer of Kristin Smart

Paul Flores, the man convicted of killing Kristin Smart, was stabbed in state prison just eight months after being attacked...

11brooks facebookJumbo v2 11brooks facebookJumbo v2
News12 hours ago

A Celebration of Middle Managers: An Opinion

Middle managers are often overlooked in discussions about leadership and management, but they play a crucial role in organizations. In...

gettyimages 1373357463 gettyimages 1373357463
News14 hours ago

Pharmacists issue warning about shortages of hundreds of drugs

A growing number of drugs are in short supply around the U.S., according to pharmacists. In the first three months...

NASA Advanced Composite Solar Sail NASA Advanced Composite Solar Sail
News15 hours ago

NASA’s Upcoming Solar Sail Mission Set to Launch into Space

Everyone understands that solar energy is abundant and practically limitless here on Earth. The same principle applies to spacecraft operating...