News
Surveillance company Flock generates controversy, and L.A. customers

Santa Cruz tried out the surveillance company Flock Safety for a little over a year before deciding it was time to move on.
Cambridge, Mass., also had enough and tore up its contract in December. Now, some officials in San Diego have begun to have second thoughts of their own.
In recent months, dozens of cities have cut ties with Flock — the nation’s largest provider of automated digital license plate readers — over fears that data the company captures is helping power President Trump’s mass deportation campaign.
The same can’t be said in one particularly surprising place: Los Angeles. Here, Flock still has an eager customer base of local elected officials, police officers, homeowners associations and businesses.
Unlike some of its competitors, the Atlanta-based company has not only marketed its plate readers to law enforcement as a vital crime-fighting tool, but aggressively pitched its product to private citizens, experts say.
“They are tremendous investigative tools,” said LAPD spokesman Capt. Michael Bland.
But for critics, there’s an obvious downside: the potential tracking of law-abiding citizens without a warrant on a scale once thought unimaginable.
“These can be really powerful tools to find someone, and identity them. But when you don’t have a suspect, everyone can be a suspect,” said Hannah Bloch-Wehba, a professor of law at Texas A&M University.
A Flock spokesperson did not respond to multiple requests for comment for this story.
Typically mounted on street poles or atop police cars, plate readers continuously monitor passing vehicles, recording their location at a specific date and time. But Flock’s AI-powered cameras go even further by also documenting other identifying vehicle details, such as make, model and color, as well as any distinctive markings like scratches or dents on a bumper.
From there, police can easily search for the location of specific vehicles in the company’s vast national database, allowing them not only to potentially retrace the whereabouts of someone suspected of a crime, but also receive predictions about future movements.
In a presentation to the Picfair Village Neighborhood Assn., Flock boasted that its plate readers had helped solve “10% of reported crime in the U.S.” In L.A., the company said, its technology had been deployed to nab porch pirates and car thieves, not to mention played a role in solving a “high-profile crime involving stolen weapons from a politician’s home.”
The problem, at least in the minds of a growing number of privacy and immigration advocates, is that the readers capture a vast amount of information not related to any specific criminal investigation. The ability of federal authorities to access Los Angeles Police Department surveillance data directly from companies like Flock or from regional intelligence hubs called fusion centers undermines the city’s promise as a haven for immigrants, critics say.
“License plate readers play a critical role in providing directions and a road map to ICE for going out to kidnap people,” said Hamid Khan, an organizer with the activist group Stop LAPD Spying Coalition, which last spring wrote a letter to the Police Commission urging it to rewrite the LAPD’s policies to ensure information on law-abiding drivers isn’t shared with federal authorities.
The commission, the LAPD’s civilian oversight panel, ordered a study on the department’s license plate reader system that is expected to be completed this summer.
LAPD officials say records collected by the plate readers are accessible only to five smaller police agencies with which the department has data-sharing agreements. Furthermore, they say the use of the readers, like with other police technology, is restricted by state laws that limit information sharing with federal agencies like Immigration and Customs Enforcement.
Plate-reading technology has been around for decades. But as the Trump administration’s deportation crackdown has ramped up, residents, privacy advocates and officials in some cities across the country have mounted campaigns urging their local governments to stop using the technology.
Much of the backlash has been aimed specifically at Flock — a heavyweight in the surveillance market that contracts with a reported 5,000 U.S. policing agencies. The company’s data-sharing with federal authorities and cybersecurity lapses have been documented by 404 Media and other outlets.
After previously denying it had federal contracts, Flock Chief Executive Garrett Langley admitted in interviews in recent months that the company has worked with U.S. Customs and Border Protection and Homeland Security Investigations. The company has since said that it has severed ties with both agencies, and responded to other concerns by giving communities more power to decide whom to grant access to state or nationwide lookup networks.
In Bloch-Wehba’s view, Flock’s meteoric rise is a triumph of marketing over results.
“There’s very little evidence on the actual impact of these technologies on violent crime rates at all,” said Bloch-Wehba, who noted an explosion of surveillance technology in 2020 to monitor protesters or enforce rules implemented to curb the spread of COVID-19 during the pandemic.
In the L.A. area, Flock has gone head to head with competitor Vigilant Solutions, which has for years supplied the majority of the LAPD’s plate readers. But today, cops tout Flock cameras at community meetings and some City Council members have paid to bring them to their districts.
Flock has also sought to flex its political might. City records show the company has stepped up its lobbying efforts at City Hall in recent years — hiring Ballard Partners, a powerful Florida-based firm whose employees now include former City Councilmember Joe Buscaino.
Many Flock plate readers, though, have been purchased by community groups. In most cases, residents band together to raise money to buy the devices, which they then either grant access to or donate to the LAPD via the Police Foundation, the department’s nonprofit charity. By donating the equipment, neighborhood groups may get to control what type of technology is installed and by whom.
“My real preference would be a fully staffed LAPD, and then we don’t have any cameras,” said Jim Fitzgerald, who lives in Venice and serves on its neighborhood council.
Roy Nwaisser, who chairs the Encino Neighborhood Council’s public safety committee, said that Flock often played up the shortage of police officers during its presentations to residents in his neighborhood.
“I personally have concerns with how Flock conducts their businesses, but they are the biggest player and if LAPD is working with them, they just have to make sure that there are those safeguards,” he said. “I don’t know that automated license plate readers are all that effective when owned by neighbors living on the street who decided to get together.”
Police executives have defended the practice, saying license plate data has helped solve untold numbers of crimes, from run-of-the-mill porch theft to high-profile cases like the 2024 attempted assassination of then-presidential candidate Donald Trump at a Florida golf course. The technology also came into play during an investigation into the fatal drive-by shooting of a 17-year-old boy at a North Hills intersection last month. According to a search warrant affidavit, detectives tracked a suspect vehicle to a home in Sun Valley after it was captured by several scanners near where the shooting occurred.
Because so many plate scanners are in private hands, it’s difficult to say how many of the devices are in operation citywide.
The L.A. Bureau of Street Lighting, which is responsible for installing the devices on city-owned property, said it has mounted 324 over five years — though that tally doesn’t include mobile plate readers.
Bland said the LAPD has 1,500 police vehicles equipped with the scanners. Police also have access to an additional 280 plate readers in fixed locations throughout the city, which are owned privately or by the department, he said. He estimated that about 120 of those readers belong to Flock.
The cameras are also integrated with the department’s new drones, which are being paid for by a $1.2-million donation from the Police Foundation.
The devices are also used for many other purposes outside of regular law enforcement. Big box retailers like Home Depot and Lowe’s have installed Flock cameras across hundreds of parking lots. Many border crossings have them. In East L.A., they are used as an emissions-reduction tool by tracking semi-trailers. USC uses them to enforce parking violations, and the L.A. Department of Transportation has deployed such cameras to nab motorists who park in bus lanes.
Since the beginning of 2025, a small-but-growing number of states and cities have enacted laws aimed at curbing the use of surveillance technology such as license plate readers.
Under California law, police agencies are required to adopt detailed usage and privacy policies governing license plate data, restrict access to authorized purposes, and regularly audit searches to prevent misuse. Gov. Gavin Newsom previously vetoed a bill that would have restricted use of such data, saying the regulations would impede criminal investigations, but the bill has been reintroduced this year.
Nearly 50 cities nationwide have opted to deactivate their scanners or cancel contracts with Flock, mostly in recent months, according to the website DeFlock.me, which has set out to map locations of the company’s cameras. Responding to public pressure, some places like Santa Cruz canceled their contracts after realizing that they had been sharing their data more broadly than they had known, including with federal authorities.
Other Flock customers, like Oakland, have dug in and decided to keep their cameras at the urging of local homeowners association representatives and small business owners — but over the objections of the city’s own Privacy Advisory Commission.
Among the places that have started to reconsider their relationship with Flock is San Diego. In December, city leaders split on the issue, but ultimately voted to keep using Flock’s scanners after a contentious public hearing meeting in which they heard from hundreds of residents opposed to the surveillance technology.
Councilmember Sean Elo-Rivera said he voted against working with Flock based on what he saw as the company’s poor track record of “data retention” and “consumer protections.” Although the city has operated Flock plate readers and cameras for years, the stakes are far higher now, he said.
“We have a presidential regime that is not only flouting the law, but takes pride in ignoring due process, in violating rights of people they deem unworthy of the rights and protections,” said Elo-Rivera, who represents an ethnically diverse district in San Diego’s Mid-City area. “They have a by-any-means-necessary approach when it comes to immigration enforcement. And now they have a tool that makes it very easy for them to track people down.”
Times staff writer David Zahniser contributed to this report.
News
See a Breakdown of Ayatollah Khamenei and Other Top Iranian Leaders
Among those killed in strikes, according to the U.S. and Israel, were Iran’s supreme leader and three of his top military commanders.
News
Get Ready For The Rubin Observatory’s Deluge Of Discoveries
It’s been about 8 months since the Vera Rubin Observatory (VRO) saw first light. Now the telescope is scanning the night sky to detect transient changes and sending alerts to astronomers and observatories around the world so they can perform follow-up observations. This alert system is one of the last milestones before the VRO starts its primary endeavour: the decade-long Legacy Survey of Space and Time (LSST).
On the night of February 24th, the VRO sent 800,000 astronomical alerts that direct astronomers’ attention to new asteroids, supernovae, and other transient phenomenon. But the VRO is just getting started. The 800,000 alerts will be dwarfed by the seven million nightly alerts the telescope is expected to deliver once it’s up to full speed.
The VRO has the largest digital camera ever made,a 3.2 gigapixel camera that takes 30-second exposures. For ten years it will image the southern hemisphere sky each night and capture visible changes. It’s building a decade-long timelapse of the night sky, and astronomers are eagerly awaiting the discoveries contained in all these images. In fact, in its first year of observations, it will image more objects than all other optical observatories in the history of humanity combined.
The telescope is poised to unleash a massive deluge of near real-time data.
“By connecting scientists to a vast and continuous stream of information, NSF–DOE Rubin Observatory will make it possible to follow the Universe’s events as they unfold, from the explosive to the most faint and fleeting,” says Luca Rizzi, a program director for research infrastructure at NSF.
Managing this massive amount of data is a critical part of the VRO. The dense data stream flows through purpose-built fiber optic cables from the observatory to Santiago, Chile’s capital city. From there it travels to Miami, Florida, then flows through existing high-speed infrastructure to the Rubin Observatory United States Data Facility (USDF) at SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory in California. Finally, the data flows through a dedicated, encrypted network to a United States Intelligence Community facility in California.
The data is turned into useful science products at the USDF. There, an automated system filters the images and generates alerts. Images of the events are available to scientists after only 60 seconds, while more complete images are released 80 hours later. The 80-hour delay allows orbiting satellites to be removed from the images.
Seven million nightly alerts is an overwhelming number. But no single astronomer faces such an unmanageable deluge. Instead, the millions of alerts will flow through a network of intelligent filters called brokers. These filters let individual researchers subscribe to different types of alerts for different objects depending on their research area: AGN, supernovae, variable stars, etc.
The VRO’s alerts are open to the public, too. Any interested party can subscribe to them and observe detected objects with personal telescopes. Citizen scientists can take part in the cornucopia of alerts through the VRO’s collaboration with Zooniverse.
*The VRO detects transients by comparing new images with previous images and detecting any changes. When changes are detected, and alert is sent. Image Credit: NSF–DOE Vera C. Rubin Observatory/NOIRLab/SLAC/AURA*
We’re accustomed to powerful new telescopes coming online, and bringing new observational capabilities. But there’s something different about the VRO. Instead of observing one target at a time, it will generate new discoveries in massive numbers, and some of them will be groundbreaking, even revolutionary.
“The discoveries reported in these alerts reflect the power of NSF–DOE Rubin Observatory as a tool for astrophysics and the importance of sustained federal support,” says Kathy Turner, program manager in the High Energy Physics program in the DOE’s Office of Science. “Rubin Observatory’s groundbreaking capabilities are revealing untold astrophysical treasures and expanding scientists’ access to the ever-changing cosmos.”
To us, the night sky can seem mostly static. We can watch the Moon gradually change night by night, and we can catch the quickly-disappearing streaks of meteors. If we’re dedicated, we can follow the planets as they plod across the heavens. We can also watch as our satellites tack across the sky. But the reality is much different, and the powerful VRO will show us how different.
The cosmos is practically alive with objects that change over time. From asteroids in our inner Solar System, to distant active galactic nuclei in other galaxies, the VRO will detect almost anything that moves or changes brightness. From the beginnings of a supernova explosion to visiting interstellar objects, the Rubin will catch them all. The VRO’s discoveries will lead scientists to a deeper understanding of everything from simple space rocks to complex and mysterious phenomena like dark energy and dark matter.
*This image shows five examples of VRO alerts for AGN. The images were captured during commissioning with the LSST Camera. Each alert includes three “postage stamp” images — the left shows the template image, the center shows the new image, and the right shows the subtracted, or difference, image. Image Credit: NSF–DOE Vera C. Rubin Observatory/NOIRLab/SLAC/AURA*
“Rubin’s alert system was designed to allow anyone to identify interesting astronomical events with enough notice to rapidly obtain time-critical follow-up observations,” said Eric Bellm, Alert Production Pipeline Group Lead for Rubin Data Management from NSF NOIRLab and the University of Washington. “Enabling real-time discovery on 10 terabytes of images nightly has required years of technical innovation in image processing algorithms, databases, and data orchestration. We can’t wait to see the exciting science that comes from these data.”
There’s more to the VRO than scientific discovery, though. By detecting large numbers of new Near-Earth Objects (NEO), the VRO will identify space rocks that pose an impact risk to Earth.
The heart of the VRO is collaboration with other telescopes. It’s alert system means that the most powerful telescopes at our disposal, including upcoming ones like the Giant Magellan Telescope and the Extremely Large Telescope, will be able to quickly target important targets. These telescopes are scientific behemoths and will image distant objects with a level of detail never before attained. Expect a steady stream of observations from these telescopes stemming from the deluge of VRO alerts.
It’s nearly impossible to overstate the VRO’s contribution to science. Researchers have worked hard to simulate what the telescope will find. According to research and simulations, the VRO will find many more gravitational lenses, including 44 lensed Type Ia supernovae detections per year. It’s expected to detect about 130 new Near-Earth Objects every night, and a total of 36,500 new NEO discoveries over ten years. It will also find more Kuiper Belt Objects, 20 billion galaxies, 20,000 galaxy clusters, and thousands of core-collapse supernovae.
The wide-angle nature of the VRO also creates massive static images filled with objects. Even without discovering any new objects or generating any alerts, the VRO’s images have scientific value.
*This VRO First Look image shows the Trifid and Lagoon Nebulae. It’s a dramatic look at how young, massive stars can affect their surroundings with their powerful radiation. Images like this one also help astronomers study how gas clouds collapse to form stars and how those stars form star clusters. Image Credit: NSF–DOE Vera C. Rubin Observatory*
The VRO is unlike any prior telescope. From its perch in the Chilean Andes, it will monitor the heavens with a thoroughness no other telescope can match. By working with other conventional yet powerful telescopes, it promises to open the heavens up to our curious minds and supercharge our sense of wonder. If you’ve ever gazed up at the night sky and pondered the big questions, your pondering is about to get a big boost.
Get ready.
News
Orange County residents fear herbicides are poisoning waterways
Residents concerned about the possible poisoning of Orange County waterways with herbicides have been making their voices heard on Instagram and pressured the county into holding a meeting on the issue Monday night.
Their effort has exposed tensions between people who see the waterways as natural creeks and county officials who see them as flood channels.
Brent Linas, a 41-year-old tech sales director in San Juan Capistrano, launched the Creek Team OC Instagram account after seeing changes on his runs along San Juan and Trabuco creeks. Lush green reeds in the channel had suddenly turned brown and lifeless, and birds had disappeared.
Linas said when county officials ignored and brushed aside his complaints, he and others turned to social media.
“We want an end to the use of herbicides in our creeks,” Linas said. “This idea that we’re just going to spray, hose down these creeks and leave them dead is unacceptable.”
Brent Linas walks through foliage along the Trabuco Creek where no herbicide was sprayed.
The account has gained more than 4,600 followers in three weeks. Linas and other residents have filed requests for records detailing the chemicals the county uses to control vegetation in the waterways, such as glyphosate, triclopyr and imazapyr.
They have posted images of workers spraying chemicals and used artificial intelligence to make illustrations resembling movie posters and old-fashioned magazine ads, some with surfers under the slogan “Endless Herbicides.”
San Juan Creek meets the ocean beside the popular surf break at Doheny State Beach. Linas, who often takes his two kids there, said surfers are angry about the spraying and are helping make fliers.
Orange County Public Works officials defend their practices.
“Vegetation management in flood control channels is conducted to maintain flood protection capacity and protect public safety,” Dave Ahern, a spokesperson for the agency, said in an email. “When chemical treatments are used, they are applied in a limited and targeted manner, consistent with applicable regulations.”
The county will hold a town hall in Dana Point on Monday night to provide information and hear from the public.
County Supervisor Katrina Foley said she generally opposes using herbicides in waterways. Her district includes San Juan Capistrano, Dana Point and the flood control channels of San Juan Creek and Trabuco Creek.
Birds rest along San Juan Creek near Doheny State Beach in Dana Point.
“I would like us to use the least toxic alternative possible, wherever possible,” Foley said in an interview. At the same time, she said, the county must keep channels clear of vegetation and at full capacity to protect neighborhoods against flooding.
The county uses only herbicides approved by state water regulators and the federal Environmental Protection Agency, and crews do not spray during bird nesting season or when endangered Southern California steelhead trout may be swimming upstream to spawn, the supervisor said.
Documents obtained by the Creek Team detail chemicals used in 2024 to “eradicate nuisance weeds” in flood control channels, or “washes,” as many Southern Californians know them. They also show the county plans to spray herbicides on more than 2,000 acres in dozens of channels and basins this year, among them the Santa Ana River and Aliso Creek.
The State Water Resources Control Board regulates herbicide use on aquatic plants and grants permits with requirements for using these chemicals.
State records show that in 2024 the county violated rules by submitting data that was “incomplete, inaccurate, or inconsistent.” Orange County Public Works wrote that it was “conducting a thorough review” to ensure compliance.
The state water board allows glyphosate, the key ingredient in the herbicide Roundup, to be used on plants in waterways.
The weedkiller has come under increasing scrutiny as Bayer, Roundup’s maker, has faced thousands of lawsuits alleging it failed to warn people it could cause cancer. (In February, the company announced a proposed $7.25-billion settlement to resolve thousands of suits by cancer patients. President Trump’s recent order to increase domestic production of glyphosate has angered activists who previously supported him.)
Supervisor Foley said she learned the county used Roundup in San Juan Creek about a year ago and made a complaint. She said the county has not used that chemical since January 2025 in the San Juan and Trabuco flood channels.
Brent Linas started a community group called The Creek Team OC to speak out on social media about how the county is using herbicides in creeks.
A record obtained by residents shows that in July, workers sprayed different herbicides in San Juan Creek, including triclopyr and imazapyr. Totaling the gallons listed, Linas calculated they sprayed 8 tons — a figure he has repeatedly used in the campaign with the demand “Stop the Ecocide!”
Foley said it was actually 34 pounds of herbicide “diluted with 8 tons of water,” and that officials are trying to use the “least amount” possible. She is pushing the county to consider alternatives, including perhaps hand weeding or even grazing goats.
“My goal is to try to find every possible way that we can avoid using chemicals,” she said.
However, she doesn’t see the washes as natural creeks.
“The purpose of the channel is not to hold habitat,” she said. “The purpose of the channel is to accommodate water during a flood.”
Linas disagrees. He previously lived for years in San Diego County, where he ran along waterways teeming with birds among reeds, willows and sycamores.
Beachgoers play in the water at the mouth of the San Juan Creek as it flows into the Pacific Ocean.
In a post that garnered more than 17,000 likes, Linas asked: “Why do Orange County’s rivers look like this when San Diego’s rivers look like this?” He showed a barren creekbed filled with cobbles, then a green wetland filled with ducks.
San Diego County “lets rivers be rivers and ecosystems manage themselves,” Linas said. (A spokesperson confirmed that San Diego County Public Works manages vegetation in waterways by hand or using equipment.)
Linas said the spraying is “destroying these vital ecosystems” and posing health threats for people who live nearby. At a minimum, he said, the county needs to notify the public when workers are going to spray.
-
Finance & Banking7 days agoEarnings From Nvidia, Home Depot, Banks, and Berkshire; Trump Speech
-
Entertainment7 days agoTim McGraw reveals most controversial song Indian Outlaw after industry tried to cancel hit
-
Finance & Banking5 days agoHere’s How Much Elder Caregivers Charge in 2026—Is Your Family Paying Fair Rates?
-
Finance & Banking5 days agoFutures Rise After Indexes Tumble on Tariff Uncertainty, AI Disruption Concerns; AMD Stock Soars on Meta Chips Deal
-
Finance & Banking6 days agoMajor Indexes Plunge Amid Tariff Uncertainty; Dow Sheds 800 Points; Bitcoin Drops, Safe-Haven Gold Rises
-
Trending5 days agoUtah Jazz rookie Ace Bailey is developing at his own pace this season
-
Trending5 days agoSome Maryland schools closed or delayed Monday due to snow
-
Trending6 days ago2-6 inches of snow expected in DC area; school delays possible – NBC4 Washington
